Indexing question

I’ve got a particularly stupid question to start the New Year. Possibly too many Jack Daniel’s the previous evening… On Ahrefs, a site scan is telling me I need to Index one of my main product pages. Before I submitted it to Indexmenow, I did a search on it and it appears. I copy and paste the link from the Ahrefs issue link and it appears in google as well. Did I drink too much or has Ahrefs been on the sauce as well ? I’ve resubmitted to Indexmenow even though it seems like it doesn’t have an issue (although Ahrefs is leading me down that path)..